Stiff Upper Quip

Stiff Upper Quip

Life gets less funny as you get older

Although people can still get funnier

James Harris's avatar
James Harris
Apr 06, 2023
∙ Paid

On May 1st, I am running the Milton Keynes Marathon to raise money for Melanoma Focus. Please sponsor me at this link, and thanks again to those who already have.


George Carlin pictured in his 1992 special, ‘Jammin’ in New York’

Some artistic forms seem to be easier to get old in than others. It’s hard to mature gracefully as a pop star, as a certain 1980s icon currently demonstrates, but there’s no reason time can’t be kind to a comedian, as you only have more routines and experience to draw from, and comedy’s certainly one area where looks aren’t generally considered a dealbreaker.

Nonetheless, I’d argue there’s a fundamental challenge to ageing in the profession of comedian, namely that life itself gets less funny as you get older. The first half of our lives, or certainly our earlier life, can seem ideally suited to the comic spirit; it’s a time of acquisition, learning by failing and, crucially, an enormous amount of social contact.

The second half of life  – if we are lucky enough to make it that far  – is on the

surface a less auspicious set of circumstances for comedy. We enter into physical and mental decline, increasing personal loss, and for all the protestations as to the depth and power of life’s second part, it inevitably culminates in death.

This isn’t territory comedy can’t work with, of course, in fact it’s territory comedy thrives in; it just tends to mean a gap opens up increasingly profoundly between the humour and the stuff the comedian makes humour out of; the comic’s position moves closer towards Howard Jacobson’s explanation for Jewish comedy, ‘The Jews are funny because life is not.’

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of James Harris.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 James Harris · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture